 The evolution of Google's advertising platforms presents dental organizations both opportunities and challenges. If you are investing in Google Ads (or thinking about it), you need to know what is actually working right now and what is just draining your marketing budget.
Since January 2023, when Local Service Ads became available for medical practices, we've observed a crucial pattern: success doesn't come from choosing between platforms, but from understanding their interconnected nature within HIPAA's unique constraints.
The Evolution of Local Service Ads (LSAs) in Dental
Since January 2023, Google's Local Service Ads have been available to dental practices, marking a significant shift in how dental organizations can advertise online. While LSAs have long served professional service businesses like HVAC companies and electricians, their implementation in the dental sector comes with unique considerations and challenges.
Understanding LSAs for Dental Practices
Local Service Ads appear above traditional Google Ads, featuring verified businesses with a distinctive Google guarantee. For dental practices, the verification process requires:
| • |
Business registration documentation
|
| • |
Valid NPI number verification
|
| • |
Current malpractice insurance documentation
|
| • |
Additional practice-specific credentials |
Additionally, the verification process may include:
| • |
Background checks on the business and owners
|
| • |
Review of team member licenses
|
| • |
Minimum number of Google reviews |
The key differentiator of LSAs is their placement: they appear above traditional Google ads and display crucial trust indicators including:
| • |
Google verification checkmark
|
| • |
Star ratings
|
| • |
Direct contact options
|
| • |
No website link (focused purely on generating direct calls) |
The HIPAA Challenge
Here's where dental practices face a unique hurdle: While LSAs typically use AI to analyze recorded calls and verify actual appointments set for billing a successful conversion, Google chooses not to record calls due to its interpretation of HIPAA regulations for dental practices. This creates a significant limitation:
| • |
Non-dental businesses: AI can verify actual appointments and transactions
|
| • |
Dental practices: Conversions are measured solely by calls lasting over 60 seconds |
This limitation often results in higher costs per actual patient acquisition, as practices pay for qualified-length calls rather than confirmed appointments.
The Hidden Requirement for Success
Our experience has shown that running LSAs in isolation rarely produces optimal results. Instead, we’ve found that LSAs require "training" through concurrent traditional Google Ads campaigns. Here's why:
| 1. |
The AI needs data to learn what constitutes a quality lead
|
| 2. |
This learning comes from your traditional Google Ads campaign data
|
| 3. |
Negative keywords and optimization in your standard campaigns help "teach" the LSA system |
PRO TIP - LSA Implementation Strategy: Start with traditional Google Ads before enabling LSAs. Our direct experience shows that running LSAs in isolation often leads to higher costs within the first two months. A well-optimized traditional Google Ads campaign should run for at least three months to help Google's AI identify quality leads
Understanding Performance Max: Opportunities and Challenges
Performance Max represents Google's latest evolution in AI-driven advertising, offering DSOs unprecedented reach across Google's entire platform ecosystem. However, much like LSAs, our experience shows that success requires a strategic approach and realistic expectations.
The Broad Reach of Performance Max
Unlike traditional Google Ads that focus solely on search, Performance Max campaigns extend your reach across:
| • |
Google Search
|
| • |
Google Discovery
|
| • |
Gmail
|
| • |
YouTube
|
| • |
Display Network
|
| • |
Discover Feed
|
| • |
Shopping
|
| • |
Google Maps
|
| • |
Additional Google properties
|
| • |
Select third-party platforms |
This expanded reach often results in lower per-click costs and potentially lower cost per conversion compared to traditional Google Ads. That said, this broad exposure comes with important considerations for dental practices.
Key Challenges for Dental Organizations
1. Intent-Based Marketing Differences
| • |
Traditional Google Ads capture users actively searching for dental services
|
| • |
Performance Max reaches users at various stages of the patient journey
|
| • |
Higher funnel exposure means more leads may be needed to generate equivalent conversions |
2. Geographic Targeting Issues
| • |
Despite setting specific geographic parameters, Performance Max sometimes treats these as suggestions rather than strict rules
|
| • |
We've observed cases of leads from entirely different states
|
| • |
Google's AI-driven approach means even their support team has limited control over these geographic anomalies |
3. Third-Party Platform Concerns
| • |
Some third-party vendors may create unauthorized or misleading advertisements
|
| • |
We've encountered instances of:| • |
Ads appearing on non-Google platforms
|
| • |
Incorrect promotion of free services
|
| • |
Misrepresentation of practice offerings |
|
| • |
These issues can damage practice credibility and create patient relations challenges |
Making Performance Max Work for Your DSO
Despite these challenges, Performance Max can be effective when:
| 1. |
Running alongside optimized traditional Google Ads campaigns
|
| 2. |
Given proper time for AI learning and optimization
|
| 3. |
Managed with clear performance metrics and expectations
|
| 4. |
Monitored closely for geographic and content accuracy |
Risk Management Strategy
| 1. |
For DSOs considering Performance Max, we recommend:
|
| 2. |
Starting with a robust traditional Google Ads campaign
|
| 3. |
Implementing clear tracking and reporting systems
|
| 4. |
Having a process for handling out-of-area inquiries
|
| 5. |
Regular monitoring for unauthorized or incorrect ad presentations |
PRO TIP - Managing Performance Max Reality: When implementing Performance Max campaigns, establish clear expectations with your practices about occasional out-of-area inquiries. While these campaigns can be effective, Google's AI sometimes treats geographic boundaries as suggestions rather than strict rules.
The Enduring Value of Traditional Google Ads
In the rush to embrace new advertising technologies, many DSOs we talk to question the relevance of traditional Google Ads. However, our extensive experience in dental marketing reveals these campaigns to be the most consistent and controllable option for practices seeking predictable growth. While newer platforms promise innovation, traditional Google Ads provide the foundational framework that powers successful dental marketing strategies.
What sets traditional Google Ads apart is their unmatched ability to deliver precise, intent-based results. When potential patients actively search for dental services in your area, these ads place your practice directly in their path. This direct connection between patient need and practice visibility creates a powerful opportunity for conversion that newer platforms often struggle to match.
Mastering Campaign Control
The true power of traditional Google Ads lies in their granular control mechanisms. Unlike the AI-driven platforms, traditional ads allow marketing teams to fine tune every aspect of their campaign, from keyword selection to geographic targeting. This level of precision helps you optimize your advertising spend across multiple locations while maintaining consistent brand messaging and performance metrics.
Consider the crucial role of negative keywords in dental advertising. Through traditional Google Ads, practices can systematically eliminate irrelevant searches, ensuring their budget focuses exclusively on qualified potential patients. This filtering process becomes increasingly valuable as practices expand across multiple locations, each with unique market characteristics.
The AI Training Ground
One of the most overlooked benefits of traditional Google Ads is their role in training newer advertising platforms. These campaigns serve as the educational foundation for both LSAs and Performance Max, teaching Google's AI systems how to identify and target quality leads for dental practices.
For example, when a DSO implements a well-structured traditional Google Ads campaign, the data collected helps refine targeting across all platforms. Key performance indicators include:
| • |
Patient acquisition patterns
|
| • |
Geographic response rates
|
| • |
Service-specific conversion metrics
|
| • |
Time-of-day engagement patterns |
Resource Allocation Strategy
For growing DSOs, the decision between internal marketing teams and agency partnerships often comes down to scale and efficiency. Our experience shows that organizations with fewer than 50 locations typically benefit most from agency partnerships, accessing specialized expertise without the overhead of a full internal team. Larger organizations might consider a hybrid approach, combining internal strategic oversight with agency-level execution.
The key to success lies in finding the right balance of control and expertise. Whether managing five locations or fifty, the fundamental goal remains the same: delivering consistent, measurable results through well-executed advertising campaigns.
Strategic Recommendations for DSO Marketing Success
Drawing from our extensive experience managing multi-location dental marketing campaigns, we've developed a comprehensive framework for maximizing advertising effectiveness across all platforms.
Building an Integrated Approach
Success in modern dental advertising requires a carefully orchestrated approach across multiple platforms. Rather than viewing LSAs, Performance Max, and traditional Google Ads as separate entities, consider them interconnected components of a unified strategy. This integration begins with establishing a strong foundation through traditional Google Ads before gradually incorporating additional platforms.
The sequence matters significantly. We recommend starting with a three-month focus on traditional Google Ads campaigns, allowing time to:
| • |
Establish baseline performance metrics
|
| • |
Develop robust negative keyword lists
|
| • |
Identify high-performing geographic areas
|
| • |
Optimize conversion tracking
|
| • |
Build a strong quality score |
Only after establishing these fundamentals should DSOs consider expanding into LSAs or Performance Max campaigns.
Budget Allocation Framework
Smart budget management across platforms requires careful consideration of each location's market dynamics. We've learned that effective budget allocation for DSOs depends heavily on market maturity and competition levels.
Consider this strategic approach to budget distribution:
| • |
Begin with a focused traditional Google Ads campaign
|
| • |
Gradually introduce LSAs once baseline performance is established
|
| • |
Test Performance Max with a smaller portion of the budget
|
| • |
Scale successful platforms based on performance data |
Managing Multi-Location Complexities
For DSOs operating across multiple markets, standardization becomes crucial. In fact, our team has even developed a systematic approach to handling location-specific challenges while maintaining brand consistency. This includes:
| • |
Creating market-specific playbooks that account for local competition, demographics, and service priorities.
|
| • |
Regular performance reviews allow for quick adjustments when market conditions change, ensuring optimal resource allocation across your network. |
Measuring Success
Traditional metrics like cost-per-click and conversion rates tell only part of the story. Modern DSO marketing requires a more nuanced approach to performance measurement. Focus on:
| • |
The quality of patient acquisitions rather than pure lead volume.
|
| • |
Track patient lifetime value alongside immediate conversion metrics to better understand the true return on advertising investment. |
Future-Proofing Your Strategy
As Google continues to evolve its advertising platforms, DSOs must remain adaptable while maintaining performance stability. Our approach emphasizes building flexible frameworks that can incorporate new technologies while preserving proven marketing fundamentals.
Key Takeaways
The success of your dental organization's digital advertising efforts ultimately depends on three core elements:
| 1. |
Expert campaign management that understands both dental industry nuances and advanced advertising techniques
|
| 2. |
A structured approach to platform integration that prioritizes stable growth over quick wins
|
| 3. |
Comprehensive performance tracking that connects advertising metrics to actual practice growth |
Whether managing campaigns internally or through agency partnerships, maintaining this balanced approach will help ensure sustainable growth across your dental organization.
 Making the Right Choice for Your DSO's Digital Marketing
Digital advertising success for DSOs isn't about choosing between LSAs, Performance Max, or traditional Google Ads—it's about understanding how these platforms work together. After managing campaigns for numerous dental organizations, we've discovered what truly drives results.
The Foundation for Success
Start with traditional Google Ads. This platform provides the control and data needed to build effective campaigns. Once established, carefully integrate LSAs and Performance Max to leverage Google's AI capabilities. Remember: AI-driven platforms need training data to perform effectively, which comes from your traditional campaigns.
Expert Implementation Matters
While in-house management might seem cost-effective, the complexity of modern dental advertising demands specialized expertise. Your advertising strategy should include:
| • |
Systematic campaign optimization across platforms
|
| • |
HIPAA-compliant conversion tracking
|
| • |
Multi-location brand consistency
|
| • |
Regular performance analysis and adjustment |
Professional Management Advantage
While some dental practices attempt to manage their own Google Ads campaigns, the complexity of modern digital advertising demands specialized expertise. Through our partnerships with DSOs, we've developed a comprehensive management approach that leverages both technology and human insight.
Professional campaign management extends beyond basic optimization. Our team's deep understanding of dental marketing allows us to anticipate seasonal trends, respond to market changes, and capitalize on emerging opportunities. This proactive approach helps DSOs maintain competitive advantages in their respective markets.
Frequently Asked Questions: Advanced Digital Advertising for DSOs
Q: With all these new AI-driven platforms, why shouldn't we just shift our entire budget to LSAs and Performance Max to stay ahead of the curve?
While it's tempting to go all-in on AI-driven platforms, this approach often leads to suboptimal results. Think of traditional Google Ads as your experienced team member who trains new hires. Without this foundation, AI platforms struggle to identify quality leads in the dental space.
Additionally, HIPAA compliance prevents these platforms from using call recordings for learning—a key feature they use successfully in other industries. Start with allocating 60-70% of your budget to traditional ads, then gradually integrate newer platforms as performance data becomes available.
Q: Our DSO operates in multiple states. How can we maintain consistent ad performance while accounting for regional differences?
Regional variation is one of the most challenging aspects of DSO advertising. The key lies in creating a "hub and spoke" campaign structure. Establish core campaigns that maintain brand consistency, then develop market-specific modifications based on:
| • |
Local procedure pricing dynamics
|
| • |
Regional insurance patterns
|
| • |
Competitive service offerings
|
| • |
Seasonal factors (like winter tourism in Florida affecting dental tourism) |
This approach allows for standardization where beneficial while maintaining flexibility for local market conditions.
Q: We're seeing longer lead attribution times than before. How should this impact our advertising strategy?
This is a crucial observation that many DSOs miss. The patient journey has indeed become more complex, often involving 7-10 touchpoints before scheduling. Rather than focusing solely on immediate conversions, develop a multi-touch attribution model that:
| • |
Tracks initial brand awareness through Performance Max
|
| • |
Monitors research phase interactions via traditional search ads
|
| • |
Measures direct booking behavior through LSAs
|
| • |
Considers offline conversions and phone calls |
This comprehensive view helps justify longer conversion windows and more nuanced budget allocation decisions.
Q: What's the biggest mistake you see DSOs making with their Google Ads strategy?
The most costly mistake we observe is treating each Google Ads platform as a separate entity rather than an interconnected ecosystem. Many DSOs will have different teams or agencies managing different platforms, leading to competing keywords, overlapping audiences, and inflated costs. Instead, develop an integrated strategy where:
| • |
Traditional campaigns inform LSA targeting
|
| • |
Performance Max insights guide overall audience strategy
|
| • |
Budget allocation flows dynamically based on cross-platform performance
|
| • |
A single team oversees the entire ecosystem to maintain alignment |
This approach typically reduces cost per acquisition by 20-30% while improving lead quality.
Take Action Now
| 1. |
Assess your current digital advertising performance
|
| 2. |
Evaluate whether your campaigns are properly integrated
|
| 3. |
Consider if your team has the expertise to optimize across platforms |
Ready to boost your digital advertising strategy and your ROI? Contact WEO Media for a comprehensive analysis of your current campaigns and discover how our dental-specific expertise can drive sustainable growth for your organization.
Learn More About Marketing Strategies
Contact us today to schedule a marketing strategy consultation. Call (888) 246-6906 to schedule your complimentary consultation with one of our senior marketing consultants today! |
